Stop Dating People With Different Values. It Won't Work.

On the very first date, Master laid it all out. Everything he believed, everything he did not. It felt intense at the time. Looking back, it was the smartest thing he could have done, because the fastest way to waste years of your life is to fall for someone whose core values are nothing like yours.

The first-date screening

He was direct about it on purpose. If you are going to find out you fundamentally disagree about the things that run a whole life, you want to find out before you are attached, not after.

"I will not marry someone whose worldview is the opposite of mine." — Master

He even gently took apart a few things I half-believed back then. I brought up chemtrails once. It took him about five minutes. It's just water. He never did it by mocking me, he did it by walking me back to the logical, grounded way of looking at things. And honestly, my own footing was a little shaky then anyway, so it landed.

The point was not to win. The point was to find out, early, whether we actually saw the world the same way.

You cannot agree to disagree on the big things

People love to say a couple can just agree to disagree. On dinner, sure. On the things that actually shape your life, no.

"You can't agree to disagree on what matters. That's why we have wars." — Marian

If you genuinely believe in evidence and someone close to you fundamentally does not, it does not just sit there politely. It shows up in every decision, every friendship, every choice about how you raise kids or spend money or who you let into your home. You will fight, and worse, you will not even be able to agree on what you are fighting about.

The Santa Claus test

Here is the framing that makes it land. Imagine you meet someone, they are gorgeous, you are getting along, and then they tell you, in total seriousness, that they believe in Santa Claus. At thirty years old. You would laugh, then realize they are not joking, then quietly panic.

"A couple inter-infects each other. One person is just better at hiding it." — Marian

That is the real danger. If you stay with someone whose beliefs do not hold up, you do not stay neutral. You drift toward them, because you love them, because their worldview becomes part of your shared life and your own identity. We have watched it happen to couples around us, one partner slowly pulled into conspiracy, or a diet that became a religion, or a whole new-age belief system, and within a few years the other one is in it too, often without ever quite agreeing to be.

Why people need to believe in something

I am not heartless about it. Humans seem wired to believe in something, and I think it comes down to death. There is a book, The Odyssey of the Sacred, that traces how religion shows up in every culture across all of human history. And the research in it is honest about something uncomfortable: believers tend to face death with more peace, and atheists like me carry more of that anxiety, precisely because we do not think anything comes after.

So when people let go of traditional religion, the need does not vanish. It just moves. It becomes a diet, a conspiracy, a guru, a wellness cult. The hole is the same shape.

Tie yourself to the mast

Which is exactly why the first few dates matter so much. It is the one window where you can still be objective, almost like a journalist interviewing a stranger, before empathy and attachment make it impossible to question them, because questioning them would mean questioning yourself.

"Do not submit to someone, or something, that does not exist." — Master

It is the Ulysses move. You tie yourself to the mast before you sail past the sirens. If you do not vet the worldview at the start, you will not be able to later, and your friend group, your community, your whole life will quietly reorganize around a belief you never actually chose. My new friend Sin Rose was raised intensely religious and became a complete atheist, and our friendship works effortlessly because we share that foundation. Every conversation just comes back to logic and psychology, no landmines.

That is what conscious submission is supposed to protect. You get to choose what you give yourself to. Make very sure it is real first.

Listen to the Full Episode: Browse all episodes

Read the Book: Why Submissive Women Are Happier

Join the Conversation: Join Happy Submissive