The Lonely Men Behind the Hot Girl Profiles

She sent me the same photo she had on her dating profile. As a selfie. After we'd been texting for days about meeting up for coffee.

That's when I knew "she" was probably a he.

This keeps happening to Master and me on dating apps. Not just dating — friendship apps too. Bumble BFF, Feeld, even some of the kink-friendly platforms. Beautiful women who match our energy perfectly, claim to be in similar relationships, want to create content together.

Then they can't take a simple selfie.

Think about it: if you're the type of woman who looks like she takes photos constantly — well-maintained, Instagram-ready, clearly comfortable with cameras — you have hundreds of selfies on your phone. My dead grandmother has more photos on her phone than some of these "women" can produce.

But when I ask for a quick selfie to verify we're both real before meeting, suddenly they can only send the same professional-looking shots from their profiles. Red flag city.

The pattern is always the same. They mirror our lifestyle exactly — age gap relationship, creative work, alternative relationship structure. They talk constantly about their "boyfriend" (never husband, never Master, always boyfriend). He likes rock music. He likes this restaurant. He likes that movie.

It's a man telling me what he likes, using a fake girlfriend as his mouthpiece.

Real women don't talk like that. When girls hang out, we talk about girl stuff — and I'm terrible at girl talk, so I'd know. These conversations feel off because they're not girl-to-girl. They're man-to-woman, filtered through a female persona.

They're always available to text but never available to meet. They travel constantly but live nearby. They're super interested in collaboration but can't commit to any actual plans. When I suggest meeting up — because that's what content creators do, we're hungry for real connections — they deflect to "maybe next month."

Next month never comes. Because next month isn't the point.

The point is the conversation itself. The attention. The fantasy of connection without the risk of real interaction.

Master explained something that hit me hard: if he went to a nice restaurant alone tonight, he'd sit alone all evening. But if I went to that same restaurant alone, I'd have options. Other women might strike up conversations. Men would approach. Couples might invite me to join them.

Male loneliness is different from female loneliness. Society doesn't create natural opportunities for men to connect, especially older married men who feel isolated in their own lives.

So they create fake female profiles and live vicariously through the attention they receive. They get to experience what it feels like to be wanted, pursued, interesting to strangers. Even if it's not real.

This isn't the same as traditional catfishing where someone wants money or sex. These men don't want to meet you. They don't want anything physical. They just want to feel less alone.

It's different from the sugar daddy sites (which are dead now anyway) or the obvious scammers. This is emotional catfishing — men who are so starved for connection that they're willing to pretend to be women just to have someone pay attention to them.

It's heartbreaking, actually.

The technology is getting more sophisticated. Master showed me demos where guys can appear on camera as female avatars in real-time. The movement tracking works, but the voice is still a problem. You can't easily match lip-sync with voice modulation and make it look natural.

For now, anyway. Give it six months.

OnlyFans requires ID verification, so these operations need a real woman's documentation to get started. Some guys use their sisters' IDs, then hire people overseas to manage the chatting while they provide the visual content.

It's an entire industry built on the monetization of loneliness.

I understand the entertainment value. I get why someone might prefer fantasy to reality — reality is messy and disappointing and requires you to shower and show up and be vulnerable.

But there's something deeply sad about a generation of men so disconnected from real human interaction that they have to cosplay as women to feel seen.

And there's something equally sad about how normalized this has become. We just accept that a certain percentage of dating app profiles are fake, that some conversations will lead nowhere, that verification has become a necessary step in any online interaction.

If you're a man who's done this — created a fake female profile just to get attention, just to feel wanted for a few hours — I'm not judging you. I'm curious about your experience.

What did you learn about female attention that surprised you? What did those conversations give you that you couldn't get as yourself? What would it take for you to feel that connected as your real self?

Because the solution isn't better fake profiles. It's creating a world where real connection is possible for everyone — even lonely married men who feel invisible in their own lives.

Sources:

Gen Z Celibacy Study (Kinsey Institute + DatingAdvice.com) — DatingAdvice.com

Listen to the Full Episode: Browse all episodes

Read the Book: Why Submissive Women Are Happier

Join the Conversation: Join Happy Submissive